A Clarification from Social Media Today: Zynga, Farmville, and Charitable Giving
The controversy originated with a report in the Brazilian publication, Folha. You can find a lengthy and detailed examination of the issues here. But to summarize, suffice it to say that there was some debate as to whether the mechanics of making donations during gameplay were confusing, potentially resulting in some of the money intended for relief to instead be applied to users' accounts for the gaming itself.
Regretfully, the two relevant posts published here on Social Media Today did not accurately articulate the nature of that controversy. Worse, the tone of the posts implied that Zynga had admitted to wrongdoing, casting the company in a negative light.
In the best of circumstances, it's challenging to ensure 100% accuracy on a site that publishes user contributed content. What makes this situation particularly unfortunate is that, at the center of this controversy is a sincere, well-intentioned, and ultimately wildly successful campaign by Zynga to help those in urgent need in Haiti. This campaign that was not the product of Zynga the corporation so much as a product of the game players and the people who work there, people who saw suffering and wanted to do something to make it better.
Even the best-administered charitable campaigns are imperfect. We know that Zynga is looking closely at how it can make future initiatives like this more transparent and efficient. Most recently they ran a campaign in which they gave 100% of all donations for Haitian earthquake relief, raising approximately $1.5 million, a staggering figure.
Zynga, of course, contacted Social Media Today and asked us to address the issue. But we want to make it clear that this clarification is not written under any duress. The fact that we published material that muddied the waters in a way that called into question people's best intentions and, worse, could make people leery of being generous in the future, is absolutely unacceptable to us. And we want to do what we can to make it right.
We're usually proud to see the posts on this site heavily tweeted and shared. Not so the two problematic posts at issue here. I hope everyone reading this will help us by giving this post equal “burn." And here at Social Media Today, we will continue to do all we can to live up to the values of our members.
Other Posts by Mark Lazen
Salon Gets The Energy Collective Wrong - March 16, 2011
SAP Wins AMI Partners 2010 Award for Best-in-Class Social Media Marketing on MyVenturePad - November 15, 2010
Social Media Today is Hiring! - October 7, 2010
A nos amis de Social Media Today, encore - May 6, 2010
Social Media Today is hiring! - April 27, 2010
» Already a member? Login now to comment!
» Not a member? Register to comment!
karrie said:
If the details of the charity campaign aren't set right and create confusions, charity initiators like Zynga may get negative ratings from the audience without being able to control or avoid that. There are a lot of scams in the charity world, this is main reason good guys pay for the bad guys. Luckily it's not the case for car donations which are usually direct material events.The Fundamentals of a Strong Social Media Plan (12,125 views)
5 Ways to Undermine Your Linkedin Profile (11,547 views)
#McFail: Why McDonald's Should Have Followed the ABC’s of Responding to Negative Feedback on Social Media (4,710 views)
How to Create a Perfect Social Media Team (4,015 views)
Jonathan Salem Baskin is an author who writes a regular column on Advertising Age & posts on his award-winning blog. More »
John Bell heads up the 360° Digital Influence team & teaches graduate studies in Digital Influence at Johns Hopkins University. More »
Don Bulmer is Vice President of Communication Strategy at Royal Dutch Shell More »
John Byrne is chairman & editor-in-chief of C-Change Media Inc. & the author or co-author of eight books. More »
Gini Dietrich Gini Dietrich is the founder and chief executive officer of Arment Dietrich, Inc. More »
Vanessa DiMauro is the CEO of Leader Networks & has been creating successful online communities for over 15 years. More »
Maggie Fox is the founder and CEO of Social Media Group & was named one of the Top 100 Marketers in Marketing Magazine. More »
Laurent Francois I lead the marketing&development hub @ Express Roularta Services, a media company. I focus on 2 main brands (L'Express, More »
Rachel Happe is a Co-Founder and Principal at The Community Roundtable & a blogger at The Social Organization. More »
JD Lasica is a consultant who is considered one of the leading authorities on social media & user-created media. More »
Brian Solis s author of Engage and is recognized as one of the most prominent thought leaders & authors in new media. More »
- YOU
- David Amerland
- Jay Baer
- Rohit Bhargava
- Sandy Carter
- Vanessa DiMauro
- Debra Ellis
- Paul Fabretti
- Sally Falkow
- Cliff Figallo
- Maggie Fox
- Brad Friedman
- Urs E Gattiker
- Paul Gillin
- Eric Goldstein
- Rachel Happe
- Shel Holtz
- John Jantsch
- Beth Kanter
- Sandy Miller
- Rohn Jay Miller
- Steve Olenski
- Tom Pick
- Eric Schwartzman
- Brian Solis
- Luis Suarez
- Hollis Tibbetts
SIFMA's Social Media Roundtable & Conference - Effectively Engaging Management, Financial Advisors & Clients
When: Fri, 2012-02-03
Integrated Social Media Marketing Conference, Singapore
When: Mon, 2012-02-06
Content Marketing Webinar led by Rebecca Lieb & 30% book discount
When: Wed, 2012-02-08
Integrated Social Media Marketing Conference, Hong Kong
When: Thu, 2012-02-09
World Communication Forum in Davos - "Communication on Top" 2012
When: Thu, 2012-02-09
Virtual Community Summit 2012
When: Thu, 2012-02-09

About Social Media Today



